Estrogen dominance means too much estrogen and not enough progesterone. I know as well as anyone that those problems are real. Many women suffer estrogen excess (see my Estrogen Excess post). Many women suffer progesterone deficiency (see 7 Superpowers of Progesterone).
Yet, I think the term ‘estrogen dominance’ is imprecise and has led to a lot of confusion.
There’s a better way to talk about estrogen and progesterone.
It’s normal to be estrogen dominant in your follicular phase
You have estrogen throughout almost all of your cycle. You have progesterone for only the final 10-14 days, regardless of how long your cycle is.
So if you have a 35-day cycle, then you won’t have any progesterone until at least day 21. Your progesterone will then be highest on day 28, and that would be the best day to test it (7 days before your period). Please read The Right Way to Test Progesterone.
A progesterone reading is of no use unless you are certain you had ovulated. You can do that by tracking your temperatures to you are in the middle of your high-temperature luteal phase. Or you can wait until your period arrives and then count back the days.
So the next time someone tests your estrogen and progesterone (either saliva or blood), do not accept the result until you ask this very important question:
Was I in my luteal phase at the time of the test? Had I ovulated at least 3 days before? Did my period come within 10 days after?
If your test turns out to have been pre-ovulation, then don’t worry about a low progesterone reading. It’s fine. It’s normal.
There’s a big difference between no progesterone and low progesterone
As I explain in my book Period Repair Manual, it’s all about ovulation. The main reason to even test progesterone is to know whether or not you ovulated. If you did ovulate, then your serum (blood) progesterone will rise to a mid-luteal reading of at least 5 ng/mL or 15 nmol/L, and your period will come within two weeks.
No progesterone. If your luteal phase reading is below 1.8 ng/mL (5.5 nmol/L), then you did not ovulate. Lack of ovulation is your problem—not low progesterone. You need to figure out why you didn’t ovulate. Do you have PCOS? Do you have a problem with thyroid? Figure out the underlying reason you don’t ovulate and correct that. You don’t need to “boost progesterone”.
⚠️ Tip: Perimenopause is a special situation. If you are over 45 and find you never ovulate, then you may not be likely to. You may need bioidentical progesterone. Read my latest post about natural progesterone.
Low progesterone. If your luteal phase reading is just 1.8 ng/mL (5.5 nmol/L), but not much higher, then you need more progesterone. The best way to get more is to improve the health of your ovarian follicles. That means reducing inflammation and getting enough ovarian nutrients such as zinc, selenium, iodine, and magnesium. Read the Road Map to Progesterone. The herbal medicine Vitex can also be helpful. Read my very popular post the Do’s and Don’ts of Vitex. You can also consider taking bioidentical progesterone.
⚠️ Tip: Be careful interpreting your result because progesterone fluctuates widely over a 90-minute cycle. A lowish reading might just mean that you tested it at a low point. Don’t read too much into it unless you also have signs and symptoms of progesterone deficiency (premenstrual spotting, PMS, heavy bleeding).
You want some estrogen
Estrogen is not bad. It is a highly beneficial hormone for both men and women. For example, estradiol (your main estrogen) improves insulin sensitivity and helps to maintain a healthy weight. (The loss of estradiol is why many women gain weight with menopause.)
It’s normal for estradiol to be very low early in your follicular phase. It should then climb to at least 80 pg/mL or 300 pmol/L at its peak a few days before ovulation. It should not go higher than 270 pg/mL or 1000 pmol/L. If it goes higher, then you need strategies to effectively clear and reduce estrogen. See my Estrogen Excess post.
You probably need to fix your gut
Your gut is probably your biggest source of excess estrogen. All estrogens (including estrogen-like environmental toxins) are detoxified through your intestinal bacteria. If your bacteria are not healthy, you will reabsorb estrogen.
The best test for estrogen excess
You won’t see reabsorbed estrogen metabolites on blood or saliva tests. That’s why neither saliva, blood, nor urine tests are all that helpful for assessing estrogen excess. The most reliable test is to observe the symptom of heavy periods.
More estrogen=heavier periods. So if your flow is heavy, then you know you have excess estrogen. You may also have progesterone deficiency—but that is a separate issue.
What is your experience with estrogen dominance? Please comment below.
Yours in health,